Sound on feature films

17 replies [Last post]
John Griffiths
John Griffiths's picture
Offline
Joined: 10 Sep 2007

We have recently bought a new plasma Panasonic TV.  While the sound from normal programmes is fine, it is impossible to watch feature films or DVDs because the sound effects and background music are so much louder than the dialog.  So you're constantly on the remote, pressing the volume up and down, either missing what they're saying or getting deafened by explosions etc.  None of the sound settings seem to do anything, e.g. SPDIF selection, V audio etc...Is it just me, or is this a common problem?  Would one of those loudspeaker sets (? Home cinema system) improve it or make it worse?

X-Trail 173 and Swift Charisma 550

Sproket
Sproket's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Apr 2008

How are you getting your feed for the film channels ? 

Are you using sky ?

Freesat ? 

Normal house aerial ?

 

Sir Sproket CJ ( BAR)

RogerL
RogerL's picture
Offline
Joined: 6 Nov 2005

You may need to turn down the bass and turn the treble up.

John Griffiths
John Griffiths's picture
Offline
Joined: 10 Sep 2007

We don't have any special film channels, just Freeview, but this problem exists even on the HD freeview, DVD and Blu-ray playback.  Picture quality is excellent and so is the sound from say a documentary.

X-Trail 173 and Swift Charisma 550

Sproket
Sproket's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Apr 2008

Is the Freeview built in to the tv ? 

Or is it a seperate box ?

Is the dvd / BlueRay player seperate or built in ?

Sir Sproket CJ ( BAR)

Past_it
Past_it's picture
Offline
Joined: 6 Aug 2010

I can't speak from experience, but I understand on new TVs which are getting thinner and thinner the quality of the sound in relation to the picture quality leaves a lot to be desred. Therefore it is prudent to get better quality speakers as seperate items.

Prof John L
Prof John L's picture
Offline
Joined: 14 Mar 2005

Hello John,

With so many different systems in the market it simply not possible to give exact instructions, but buried somewhere in the equipments menus will be some features that will allowyou to adjust variuous aspects of the sound. 

Either get you 5 year old grandson to sort it for you  or take the risk of being laughed at in the pub and look in theh instructions. Failing that talk to your supplier.Wink

All advice and opinions given are my own and are given in good faith, unless quoted with references, The reader should verify the information given with relevant professionals

ZeGecko
ZeGecko's picture
Offline
Joined: 1 Feb 2012

In December we bought a new Smart TV, after weeks of looking and listening to numerous TV's sound and picture quality in the £800 to £1100 region we found that Samsung offered the best picture quality and sound.  I annoyed many store staff playing with the sound and settings and then walking away three rows from the set to check out how picture and sound was. My money so I only part with it when the product is up to scratch.
But Prof is correct you need to make sure you have got fully in to the setting for optimum performance. Our son bought a theatre sound system and took it back within the stores returns period after he found speakers that "fizzed and popped" ( ??) and then bought a better system elsewhere for less money.

Lord Braykewynde
Lord Braykewynde's picture
Offline
Joined: 19 Jul 2005

We had a Toshiba and the sound was crap. No amount of tweaking would correct and others tried as well. it was only 2 years old so gave it to our grandaughter and while reading reviews and looking at customer feedback online I went for the LG LED Smart TV. The sound quality is 100% better than the Toshiba and I haven't had to tweak it. Infact the whole system is more user friendly and the LED backlit picture is what persuaded me to buy it in the first place. Like someone else said, to get a perfect audio experience you will need a surround sound system.

Incidentally the salesman told me that the day before he had taken back in a Toshiba set that a customer had brought back because of the poor sound. I can only explain it as if people had buckets on their heads whilst talking. All the reviews and feedback I read about Toshiba mentioned the poor sound.

Last week there was an article in the Express saying about the poor sound quality on modern films compared to years gone by so maybe this is also a factor.

“If there is anyone on the forum whom I have not insulted, I apologise profusely. ”

RogerL
RogerL's picture
Offline
Joined: 6 Nov 2005

Good "theatre" systems can actually make it worse - the sound is recorded at specific levels and transmitted digitally but because a good theatre system will have better speakers than TVs it's the mid-range and bass that will benefit most, but these are the very frequencies that film makers use to make things more dramatic.

I love listening to rock music programmes, eg Glastonbury, through our theatre system but for normal TV that would be unbearable so I just use it's normal speakers with the bass turned down.

Surfer
Surfer's picture
Offline
Joined: 14 Mar 2005

Lord Braykewynde wrote:

We had a Toshiba and the sound was crap. No amount of tweaking would correct and others tried as well. it was only 2 years old so gave it to our grandaughter and while reading reviews and looking at customer feedback online I went for the LG LED Smart TV. 

Isn't the LG a rebranded Goodmans?  We have a LG in the bedroom and no issues with it.

Toyota HiLux Surf 3.0L auto chased by a Lunar Delta TI with a pussy and 4 Yorkshire terriers